Keep in mind that I only played the game for 3 hours, I don’t feel like I played long enough to give a reliable impression. With that in mind, the game shows a lot of promise. The game is giving me pleasant feelings that I haven’t felt in a long time. The sense of wonder, not knowing what to expect next and nostalgia based on the structure of the game and the FF lore/love that is apparent to see.
The game feels very old school with the towns (it was not possible to enter buildings in the town that I saw btw), dungeons, cutscenes then gameplay, random battles etc. This is not a bad thing. I enjoy it when it’s done right along with QOL improvements.
The battle and upgrade system surprised me in a good way. You have the freedom to change how the battle system feels. You can choose wait mode to pick commands without the monsters attacking you, active mode for the opposite effect and semi-active for in between (time stops when you pick magic/items etc). You can change the style of the fights where you have your typical command menu or a short-cut interface that looks more modern. You can change the speed of the battles in the menus and also make the battles go quicker during fights.
The stacking system is something that I didn’t understand before playing the game but now I think it’s pretty great and interesting. Whether it remains interesting depends on the difficulty later on. The upgrade system gives you a lot of freedom to evolve your monsters. You can go back to previous evolution without penalties from what I have read.
The dialogue is charming and funny, but it is typical anime style if you are turned-off by that. The smart sister, the brother who is always treated like an idiot etc. I am trying to ignore the forced stereotypical treatment of the characters, the rest is fun. Description about the monsters is also funny. The rants during dungeons adds to the personality.
To continue with the QOL that I mentioned earlier, besides the battle system, it is also apparent in other ways. You always have a summary of every chapter to go back to. You have information about the side quests in the menu. Every tutorial that is mentioned can be found in the menu and more such examples. It is easy to leave the game for weeks and then continue with it.
It really depends on your expectations and what you like. I am having a blast with it, but I also didn’t have high expectations to begin with. I don’t expect the best graphics etc.